Long Island Pies

We all love pie on Thanksgiving, don’t we?

I love pie for dessert and I am sure there are lots of pie lovers out there.

There are a few locations on Long Island that have some delicious fresh pie that you just have to get your hands on this season.


Check out these great Long Island locations:

1.Briermere Farms


“All of our pies, bread, muffins, cookies, cakes, jam, and jelly are made right here on our farm from scratch. There are no pre-prepared ingredients or fillings bought for use. Most of the fresh fruit used in our bakery is grown right here on our farm”

Located at: 4414 Sound Avenue in Riverhead

Fall Hours: Open Daily, 9am – 5:00pm. Weekends, Until 5:30pm

Phone: 631-722-3931


2. Jericho Cider Mill


“Known for their delicious cider, they also have pies that are out of this world. They are taking Thanksgiving orders now!”

Located at: 213 Route 106 in Jericho, NY 11753

9:00 AM to 6:00 PM Daily – September through May

Phone: 516-433-3360


3. White Post Farms


Like on Facebook—–> click here

“ All of our breads and pies are fresh baked daily and available for pickup everyday. We use only the freshest ingredients in all of our breads and pies…”

Located at: 250 Old Country Road, Melville, New York 11747

Open Daily at 10am

Phone: 631-351-9373


4. Wickham’s Fruit Farm


“Only Wickham’s fruit winds up in Wickham’s pies”

Located at: 28700 Main Road Cutchogue, NY

Phone 631-734-6441


5. Young’s Farm


Located at: Hegemans Lane Glen Head, NY 11545

“a variety of home made fruit pies, including apple, cherry, pumpkin and peach, and other baked goods such as cookies, muffins and biscuits”

Phone: 516-626-3955

Hours: Tuesday through Saturday 10am-5pm ,  Sunday 11am-4pm and Closed Mondays


6. Windy Acres


                                                                  Located at: 3810 Middle Country Road in Caverton,NY

                                                                                                         Phone: 631-727-4554


7. Davis Peach Farm


I love their Peach Pie and you have got to try their homemade Sangria Mix.

 Located at: 561 Hulse Landing Road in Wading River

Phone: 631-929-1115


8. Ann Marie’s Farm Stand

Bring one of our homemade pies to Thanksgiving dinner and you’re guaranteed to be invited back!

Order your Thanksgiving pies today! Message us, call Maryanne at 371-6197 or stop in.


9. Fitz in The Kitchen

A local Momee Friend of mine is Fitz in the Kitchen! She is an amazing baker and cook…


Check out her Facebook page —-> click here

Where will you get your pies? Order them as soon as possible!

Posted by

My name is Anne and I am a local mommy blogger ... Momee Friends is all about Long Island and all things local with the focus on family

Leave a Reply